Dendrochronology
From CreationWiki, the encyclopedia of creation science
Dendrochronology (also called tree-ring dating) is a technique of dating past climatic changes through a study of tree ring growth. Each year a tree adds a layer of wood (xylem) to its trunk and branches thus creating the annual rings we see when viewing a cross section. Wide rings are produced during wet years and, narrow rings during dry seasons. These changes in tissue formation can be used to calculate age of the tree itself or surrounding archaeological artifacts.
Contents |
History
Clark Wissler of the American Museum of Natural History can be credited as one of the first individual scientists to realize the importance of such naturally occuring rings in trees can be used to tell how old it is. Wissler worked with A. E. Douglass now considered the father of dendrochronology at the University of Arizona to further studies and solidification of such dating as a worthwhile scientific endeavor. [1] [2]
Tree-Ring Formation
Xylem is a plant tissue that can be found within trees, being responsible for transporting water and mineral nutritients, from the root of vascular plants, distributing it to the necessary parts. [3] Pith is found at the center of the tree stem, then rings can bee seen followed by a layer that insulates between what is called vascular cambium (the source of xylem and phloem) and the outer appearance of the tree, or its bark.
Each year a new layer of xylem is produced, thus giving us the tree rings we all can observe and count. These tree-rings are wood cells formed within a year or growing season, thin walled cells formed in the early growing season (earlywood) and thicker walled cells produced later in the growing season (latewood).
Apparent old ages
By using dendrochronology scientists have dated certain living trees or their root systems in certain cases as having ages in excess of what is expected given the Biblical chronology of the global flood.
National Geographic reported in April of 2008 [4] that scientists led by Leif Kullman, professor at Umea University's department of ecology and environmental science in Sweden found the worlds oldest growing tree root system.
| “ | Trees much older than 9,550 years would be impossible in Sweden, because ice sheets covered the country until the end of the last Ice Age around 11,000 years ago, Kullman noted. | ” |
| “ | "Prior to our studies the general conception was that spruce migrated to this area about 2,000 years ago, so now you will have to rewrite the textbooks," Kullman said. | ” |
These types of findings are used by evolution proponents to aid their debate in silencing anything related to Biblical chronology. The relevant dates include the global flood which was around 2300 BC, and the seven day creation week with the inclusion of trees that happened around 4004 BC. The global flood was so complete that no living thing was left, and logically what would follow is the lack of possibility for there to be a tree older than about 2000 years.
Instead of re-writing the textbooks as Mr. Kullman puts it, perhaps he should take a look at the science being practiced that is causing these apparent old ages for trees that couldn't possibly of existed so long. Kullman's findings present a case that is disputed by Gerald Aardsma who found that trees can produce multiple rings in a wet year. As well as one of the founders of the modern creation science movement, Walter Lammerts, who documented in the lab that trees can also display extra rings in short drought periods.[5]
Principles of Dendrochronology
There are seven dendrochronological principles that contain certain assumptions, that are used as a framework or theory to interpret tree-ring data. The most prominent of such assumptions, uniformitarianism is also an assumption that is quite prevelant within evolutionary science.
Uniformitarian
The uniformitarian principle is the assumption that present day physical and chemical processes responsible for the connection of enviornmental change and tree-ring formation is the same today as it has been in the past.
Limiting Factors
The limiting factor principle is one which states that rings can only form as fast as the limiting factor. For example, if rainfall is the limiting factor than tree rings, or essentially tree growth is subordinate to the limiting factor of rainfall.
Aggregate Tree Growth
The aggregate tree growth principle states that many conditions, both natural and human induced are responsible for any one tree-ring series growth pattern. Many factors of a tree growth patterns have to be taken into account, however in some cases one factor may be left out as potential data due to isolation of a different factor that requires study.
The four factors taken into account are:
- Tree growth related to normal physiological aging processes within the tree itself.
- Climate or weather induced factors.
- Outside of the forest factors such as disease, or insect problems.
- Random natural or human caused processes that effect tree growth.
Ecological Amplitude
The principle of ecological amplitude recognizes the ability for different species of trees to grow in many locations or specialized habitats. This is important to consider because useful trees for dendrochronology are often found near zones of their natural range.
Site Selection
The site selection principle recognizes that certain species of trees propagate and survive better in certain conditions than others do. A tree-ring series found in certain species of trees that have high survivability near desert like conditions would mean that a dendrocrhonologists could deliberately sample those trees to glean past drought conditions.
Crossdating
The most practiced principle of dendrochronology is achieved through comparing dates of tree-ring series from one tree and many other trees from a different location. Once tree rings from many separate trees are obtained within the same general area and those with corresponding or comparable patterns are observed and then compiled as a set of data crossdating has been achieved. Through many over-lapping ring chronologies, what is called a master dendrochronology can be defined and used to interpret past conditions more precisely. [6]
Replication
The principle of replication states the need of more than one stem radius per tree and more than one tree per site. Essentially samples will range up to many trees per site or even many sites of trees. This is an attempt to identify and minimize noise or environmental factors of little interest. [7] [8]
Gallery
 Woody vascular plant stem cross-section |
References
External Links
Creationist links
- Tree ring dating (dendrochronology) by Don Batten, Ph.D.
- Are tree-ring chronologies reliable? by Mark Aardsma. May 2001
- Compatibility of Biblical Chronology with C-14 Age by R. H. Brown. Origins 21(2):66-79 (1994)
- Can Tree Rings Be Used To Calibrate Radiocarbon Dates? by R. H. Brown, Origins 22(1):47-52 (1995).
- More Creationist Research, PART II: BIOLOGICAL RESEARCH, Variable Production of Growth Rings in Bristlecone Pines by Duane T. Gish, Ph.D., Creation Research Society Quarterly 26(1):5 June, 1989
- Tree-Rings Dating and Multiple Growth Ring Per Year Aardsma, Dr. Gerald E., Creation Research Society Quarterly, volume 29, March 1993, pp. 184-189.
Secular links
- Dendochronology by Rachel Neff, Erin Woike, Laura Stevens, Eric Claus, Eric Weaver.
- Time and Cycles Lesson: "Logs of Straw: Dendrochronology" by U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey.
 Browse |
See Also
| |||||||||||
