Talk:Fossils sorted by ability to escape (Talk.Origins)

Post comment,
or browse more talk.

Please observe discussion policy and use talk pages only for reviewing articles.

Re: "By isolating differential escape Talk Origins is turning it into a Straw Man (http://www.datanation.com/fallacies/straw.htm)."

This is blatant dishonesty. Talk Origins does not isolate the three mechanisms - in fact, they comment on their combined effects in the section immediately after the three sections you have quoted from - a section which you have omitted to address. Omitting their discussion of the three mechanisms acting in concert is bad enough, but to then turn round and accuse them of not addressing the possibility is simply disgusting.

Roy 20:43, 13 Dec 2004 (GMT)

Talk.Origins does indeed address the mechanisms in their combined form [1]. However, the previous three sections isolate them, making each seem like it is stating that it is the sole process. PrometheusX303 20:28, 13 April 2006 (GMT)